Earl haig essay earl haig is the best high school in toronto there are many public high school in toronto, but there are some best and bad high schools earl haig is one of the best school in toronto. Essay on why haig is bad leader what kind of leader was haig interpretation – a view from somebody’s point of view that may not be necessary be true the battle of the somme occurred on the 1th of july 1916, with the english and french army fighting against the german english’s army’s leader, haig. Was general haig a donkey or a great commander - assignment example in 1914, at the outbreak of the war, haig was leader of the 1st corps and by 1915 was commander of the 1st army we will write a custom essay sample on any topic specifically for you for only $1390/page. Field marshal haig: “hero or butcher of the somme” i consider the field marshal as a butcher and a hero for numerous reasons while the insinuation of haig as a butcher ignores many positives that he possessed, the implication of him being a hero also neglects negatives that the field marshal obtains. Was haig an incompetent leader essays and research papers search some people have the view that british generals like haig were incompetent leaders is a very harsh view against leaders as the source straight away agrees with the interpretation that incompetent leaders like haig just sent people to death this.
Best answer: the 'haig was a good leader' school was started by john terraine in his 'douglas haig:the educated soldier' (1963) mainly in response to alan clark's 'the donkeys' (1961)as terraine was the more prestigious historian at the time,his view prevailed. Published: tue, 06 jun 2017 the issue of douglas haig’s role as a general on the western front, during the battle of the somme in 1916, has been thoroughly questioned by many historians to date. Haig like a lot of military leaders across many eras and wars insisted on seeing wwi as the type of war that he was familiar with and although he realised the necessity to use new tactics and strategies he didn't understand how to use them properly.
Haig was a general in the first world war, and it is said that it was his fault that the battle of the somme resulted in masses of deaths john keegan- a modern historian says that ‘haig was an efficient and highly skilled soldier who did much to lead britain to victory in the first world war. Sir general haig was in charge of the british at the time people think that haig should be remembered as the “butcher of the somme” because he sent thousands of british soldiers to their deaths some people thought that haig was a donkey leading lions. Essays related to poor leadership 1 sir douglas haig has received severe criticism for his leadership of the british army in the battle of somme this undoubtably is a result of poor leadershiphistorian liddell hart believed that haig was a poor strategist, inflexible and wasteful of men's lives, had little knowledge of infantry war.
What kind of leader was haig essay sample interpretation – a view from somebody’s point of view that may not be necessary be true the battle of the somme occurred on the 1th of july 1916, with the english and french army fighting against the german. Haig as a leader essay haig as a leader i think haig was a bad leader who made many critical mistakes during the battle of passchendaele. Haig alexander is an american statesman and politician, military leader, diplomat secretary of state, commander-in-chief of the nato armed forces in europe four-star general alexander haig was born in a suburb of philadelphia. Did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme b pages: 9 words: 2286 we will write a custom essay sample on did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme specifically for you for only $1390/page ” this source says that haig was a flawless leader and a genius the writer says that haig led his team and britain. Rumble resources limited (rtr) is an australian-based mineral haig butcher of the somme essay exploration and haig butcher of the somme essay building conservation dissertations development company established for the purpose of acquiring a portfolio of highly.
Allan massie reviews the good soldier: a biography of douglas haig by gary mead when field-marshal earl haig died in 1928 it was estimated that at least one million people watched the funeral. Critics of haig often cite this stubbornness, along with the failed offensives he presided over, as a reason haig was yet another incompetent great war general ultimately, haig is a leader mired in controversy. This essay will investigate to what extent haig’s contribution to the body count can be acquitted through four main issues as argued by hew strachan and gary sheffield these issues entail an untrained army, artillery issues, new technologies and a lack of communication, with analysis of haig’s strategies as supporting evidence. Haig as a leader i think haig was a bad leader who made many critical mistakes during the battle of passchendaele from looking at the sources i can see many bad views of haig as a war leader, although some good views can also be detected.
How far do your sources support or contradict the interpretation that british generals like haig were incompetent leaders world war 1 began in the month of july 1914 and lasted until 11 november 1918. Haig was also heavily criticised for the ridiculous length of the battle, this was simply because it could have been ended much sooner than it was, and this would have even prevented britain in constantly finding fault in haig’s leadership skills. Interpretations of haig : the great haig debate, the war years, haig's reputation in the 1920s, changing attitudes in the 1930s, lloyd george's war memoirs, into the 'sixties, john terraine, for haig, against haig, towards a synthesis, academic appraisal versus popular impression, a personal conclusion footnotes.
Haig was a quiet and shy man but he was intelligent and ambitious and had great self-confidence perhaps his greatest general haig : hero, butcher or bungler the man pictured to the right is sir douglas haig he was the british i found the criticism really rather difficult and sad as his leadership was paramount / most. Interpretation that haig was a butcher: source b2 was written by p - interpretation that haig was/wasn't a butcher (source analysis) introduction smith a private in the 1st border regiment during the somme describes the battle from how he saw it during the battle he described it as “pure bloody murder” on the battlefield and. Haig as an efficient and highly skilled soldier essay - haig as an efficient and highly skilled soldier during the first world war, field marshall haig was a military leader from britain.
1914-1918 essays on leadership & war by john terraine : introduction by correlli barnett share articles the war to end all wars: the american military experience in world war i here come the girls the women volunteers at the army pay office woolwich from august to october 1914 in 1918 haig and his army commanders won their victory. Considered assessment of the great war career of field marshal douglas haig douglas haig was appointed as commander of the bef’s 1st army corps at the outbreak of world war one in 1914 with sir john french as commander in chief of the british army. Free haig papers, essays, and research papers haig as a leader - haig as a leader i think haig was a bad leader who made many critical mistakes during the battle of passchendaele.